RRC ID 86467
Author García-Roselló E, González-Dacosta J, Lobo JM.
Title Geographic biases undermine environmental representativeness of European biodiversity data.
Journal Sci Total Environ
Abstract Biases and gaps in biodiversity data lead to significant disparities in species descriptions and distribution patterns across taxonomic groups. Although various modelling approaches can help address these gaps, they require the available data to be environmentally representative. In this study, we use data from the Global Biodiversity Information Facility (GBIF) to examine geographical biases, data gaps, and spatial completeness patterns in species distribution records for the 20 main classes of terrestrial organism in Europe-the world's oldest region for taxonomic and natural history research. By identifying spatial units with complete inventories for each class, we assess their quantity, distribution, and capacity to represent the environmental variability of the European subcontinent. Our results reveal high spatial heterogeneity and substantial variation among taxa in the number of well-surveyed units. Vertebrates and vascular plants have several times more well-surveyed cells than invertebrates and mosses. In terms of environmental representativeness, the findings highlight the uncoordinated and opportunistic accumulation of biodiversity data and the urgent need for improved coverage. This situation raises concerns about the reliability of current biodiversity data for accurately characterizing species distributions and limits the effectiveness of species distribution models. Given the scale and urgency of the biodiversity crisis, waiting for complete and reliable data before taking conservation action is not a viable option.
Volume 996
Pages 180178
Published 2025-7-30
DOI 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2025.180178
PII S0048-9697(25)01818-2
Description J-OBIS data were referenced. NIES data were referenced. BiodiC-J data were referenced.
PMID 40743755
MeSH Animals Biodiversity* Conservation of Natural Resources* Environmental Monitoring* / methods Europe
IF 6.551
Resource
GBIF Herbaceous and arboreous plants list on the Komaba Campus of University of Tokyo, Japan Vascular Plant Specimens of Yamagata Prefectural Museum Mammal specimens of Ryukyu University Museum (Fujukan) Bird specimens of Obihiro Centennial City Museum Entomological Specimens of Museum of Nature and Human Activities, Hyogo Pref., Japan Hemichordata collection of National Museum of Nature and Science Insect specimens of Sagamihara City Museum Fern (Pteridophyta) specimens of Toyama Science Museum Vascular plant specimens of Omachi Alpine Museum Butterfly Specimens of Yamaguchi Prefectural Yamaguchi Museum Lepidoptera collection of National Museum of Nature and Science Chironomid Specimen records in the Chironomid DNA Barcode Database. Insect Specimens of Ibaraki University (Faculty of Science) Platyhelminth collection of National Museum of Nature and Science Plant specimens of Ishikawa Museum of Natural History Crabs from Vietnam and Indonesia Occurrence dataset of demersal fish and benthic organisms in the deep-sea off the northeastern coast of Japan, recorded by ROV after the 2011 Earthquake off the Pacific coast of Tohoku Effects of temperature and red tides on sea urchin abundance and species richness over 45 years in southern Japan Spider specimens of Kushiro City Museum Mollusca collection of National Museum of Nature and Science Mammal specimens of Obihiro Centennial City Museum Bryophyte specimens of Kanagawa Prefectural Museum of Natural History Survey data of rocky shores on the Monitoring sites 1000 project, BDCJ Species list recorded by baited cameras at deep sea area in Japan Mollusca specimens of Toyama Science Museum Bryophyte Specimens of Ishikawa Museum of Natural History (ISKW) Fish specimens of Natural History Museum, Kishiwada City Insect specimens of Himeji City Science Museum Plant Specimens of The Cattle Museum Bird Specimens in the Museum of Nature and Human Activities, Hyogo, Japan Long-term fauna and flora records of the experimental forests of the Forest Research Station of Hokkaido University, Japan Spermatophyte collection of Himeji City Science Museum DNA barcoding on chironomid specimens collected from ponds in Hyogo, Japan CMarZ (Census of Marine Zooplankton)-Asia Database Plant specimens of Toyota City Nature Sanctuary Ferns and Lycophytes Specimens of Kawasaki Municipal Science Museum Herbarium Specimens of The Kagoshima University Museum (KAG) Shallow-water fauna of Sagami Bay Kinorhyncha specimens of Ryukyu University Museum (Fujukan) Insect specimens of Otaru Museum Insect specimens of Kaizuka City Museum of Natural History Fish specimens of Bihoro Museum Insect specimens of Rikuzen-Takata City Museum Insect specimens of Iwate Prefectural Museum A nest-site survey of Barn swallow at railroad stations in the Kinki District,south-central Japan Insect specimens of Toyota City Nature Sanctuary Survey data of algal beds on the Monitoring sites 1000 project, BDCJ Asia-Pacific Dataset Crustacean specimens of Kitakyushu Museum of Natural History & Human History Bird specimens of Kawasaki Municipal Science Museum Insect specimens of Kushiro City Museum Vascular plant specimens of the herbarium of the Tohoku University (TUS) Spermatophyta Specimens of Kawasaki Municipal Science Museum Marine Invertebrata specimen database of Osaka Museum of Natutal History Botanical collection of Gifu Prefecture Museum Fish monitoring data in Lake Kasumigaura Spider specimens of Iwate Prefectural Museum Aschelminth collection of National Museum of Nature and Science Echinoderm specimens of Ryukyu University Museum (Fujukan) Occurrence data of seagrasses in Southeast Asia extracted from literature Sipuncula collection of National Museum of Nature and Science Vascular Plants Collection of National Museum of Nature and Science Insect Specimens of Kitami Region Museum of Science History and Art Ogasawara DNA barcode database Invertebrate collection of Hokkaido Museum Gunma Museum of Natural History, Bryophyta Specimen Amphibian specimens of Obihiro Centennial City Museum Odonata Specimens of Yamaguchi prefectural Yamaguchi Museum Plant Specimen Database of Tama Forest Science Garden, Forestry and Forest Products Research Institute, Japan Gunma Museum of Natural History, Crustacea Specimens Mammal specimens of Oiso Municipal Museum Migratory shorebirds (sandpipers and plovers) in Hokkaido Lepidoptera specimen database of Japan Insect specimens of Obihiro Centennial City Museum Marine Biological Sample Database, JAMSTEC Bryophyte specimens of Iwate Prefectural Museum Plant specimens of Otaru Museum Project for Reef Fish Monitoring Vascular plant specimens of Akita Prefectural Museum Kelp Dataset Akita Prefectural Museum, Insect Collection Specimen based records and geographic locations of carabid beetles (Coleoptera) collected mainly by Dr. Kazuo Tanaka Crustacean collection of the National Museum of Nature and Science Crustacea Collection of Natural History Museum and Institute, Chiba Reptile specimens of Yamagata Prefectural Museum The south coast survey of Hatakejima Islands from 1969 Annelida collection of National Museum of Nature and Science Survey data of seagrass beds on the Monitoring sites 1000 project, BDCJ The entire coast survey of Hatakejima Islands from 1983 Tardigrad collection of the National Museum of Nature and Science Plant specimens of Komatsu City Museum Plankton&BenthosResearch Bryozoans Specimens of Akita Prefectural Museum Brachiopods Specimens of Akita Prefectural Museum Insect Specimens Deposited in Saga Prefectural Space and Science Museum, JAPAN Specimens of Class Pycnogonida of Akita Prefectural Museum Specimens of Phylum Nemertea of Akita Prefectural Museum Nagoya-Mammals Insect specimens of Oiso Municipal Museum Reptiles Specimens of Akita Prefectural Museum Akita Prefectural Museum, Hiroki Watanabe Collection Millipedes Specimens of Akita Prefectural Museum Araneae Specimens of Kawasaki Municipal Science Museum Specimens of Phylum Porifera of Akita Prefectural Museum Crustacea specimens of Kuroshio Biological Research Foundation Insect specimens of Yonezawa Insectarium Birds Specimens of Akita Prefectural Museum Type Collection of the Seto Marine Biological Laboratory, Kyoto University Pycnogonidea specimens of Kuroshio Biological Research Foundation Invertebrate collection of the Seto Marine Biological Laboratory, Kyoto University Hagfishes Specimens of Akita Prefectural Museum Arthropoda Collection of the Seto Marine Biological Laboratory, Kyoto University Mollusca specimens of Kuroshio Biological Research Foundation Annelids Specimens of Akita Prefectural Museum Herbarium of Hokkaido University Museum (SAPS) Cnidaria Collection of the Seto Marine Biological Laboratory, Kyoto University Mollusca specimens of Oiso Municipal Museum Ascidians Specimens of Akita Prefectural Museum Nemertean specimens of Ryukyu University Museum (Fujukan) Fish collection of the Kagoshima University Museum Flora of Japan Specimen Database Echinoderms Specimens of Akita Prefectural Museum Bryophyte Collection of Natural History Museum and Institute, Chiba Actinopterygius Specimens of Akita Prefectural Museum Amphibians Specimens of Akita Prefectural Museum Vascular Plant Collection of Natural History Museum and Institute, Chiba Centipedes Specimens of Akita Prefectural Museum Echinodermata specimens of Kuroshio Biological Research Foundation Echiurans Specimens of Akita Prefectural Museum Bryophytes specimens of Akita Prefectural Museum Cetacean Stranding Data in Hokkaido Herbarium Specimens of Museum of Nature and Human Activities, Hyogo Pref., Japan Insect Collection of Saitama Museum of Natural History The 6-7th National Survey on the Natural Environment: Vegetation Survey Pteridophyta specimens of Iwate Prefectural Museum Bee occurrence data collected in "Hanamaru-Maruhana national census (Bumble bee national census)" in Japan JAMSTEC_MULTISPLASH2006_SagamiBay_Siphonophora Herbarium, University Archives and Collections, Fukushima University, Japan (FKSE) Mammalians Specimens of Akita Prefectural Museum Chondrichthyans Specimens of Akita Prefectural Museum Angiospermatatophytina Collection of Saitama Museum of Natural History Malacostracans Specimens of Akita Prefectural Museum Insect Collection of Yokosuka City Museum Observation records of Amphibians Molluscus specimens of Toyohashi Museum of Natural History Echigo-Matsunoyama Museum of Natural Science, Usuke Shiga butterfly collection Ibaraki Nature Museum, Arthropoda collection Ibaraki Nature Museum, Mollusk collection Scleractinia specimens of Kuroshio Biological Research Foundation Ibaraki Nature Museum, Mammals collection Gorgonacea specimens of Kuroshio Biological Research Foundation Ibaraki Nature Museum, Fish collection Ibaraki Nature Museum, Birds collection Crustacea specimens of Ryukyu University Museum (Fujukan) Fixed Point Survey for Shorebirds of the family Scolopacidae and Charadriidae Bird specimens of Saitama Museum of Natural History Fish specimens of Toyama Science Museum Bird Specimens of The Cattle Museum Herbarium of Shinshu University Flatworm specimens of Ryukyu University Museum (Fujukan) Ibaraki Nature Museum, Bryophyta collection Plant specimens of Parthenon Tama Museum (PTHM) Specimens of Class Maxillopoda of Akita Prefectural Museum Plant specimens of Obihiro Centennial City Museum Ibaraki Nature Museum, Amphibians and Reptiles collection The 24th field study tour in Sesoko, Okinawa - a citizen science, observations of invertebrates Vascular plant specimens of Nagano Environmental Conservation Research Institute, Nagano Prefecture Plant Observation Records of Japan Plant specimens of Oiso Municipal Museum Ibaraki Nature Museum, Algae collection Mollusk Collection of Yokosuka City Museum Mammal specimens of Saitama Museum of Natural History Insecta specimens of Takao Visitor Center Shellfish specimens of the Nishinomiya Shell Museum, Japan Hymenoptera Specimens of Yamaguchi prefectural Yamaguchi Museum Moss specimens of Kushiro City Museum Fish collection of the Museum of Nature and Human Activities, Hyogo Arachnid specimens of Ryukyu University Museum (Fujukan) Mollusca specimens of Wakayama Prefectural Museum of Natural History Akita Prefectural Museum, Observation Records of Birds in Akita Prefecture Chaetognatha collection of National Museum of Nature and Science Vascular plant specimens of The Shirakami Research Center for Environmental Sciences, Hirosaki University Ibaraki Nature Museum, Vascular Plants collection Mollusc specimens of Parthenon Tama Museum (PTHM) Kitami Region Museum of Science History and Art(KIRM) Diptera Specimens of Yamaguchi prefectural Yamaguchi Museum JODC Dataset Fish Collection of Yokosuka City Museum Bryophyte specimens of Toyota City Nature Sanctuary (TCNS). Ground Beetle of Japan Specimen Database Insecta collection of Ishikawa Museum of Natural History (ISKW) Plant specimens of Mie Prefectural Museum Fish Collection of Hokkaido University Bird specimens of Oiso Municipal Museum Mammal specimens of Toyota City Nature Sanctuary Bryophyte specimens of National Museum of Nature and Science (TNS) Herbarium Specimens of Bonin and Ryukyu Islands Plant specimens of Toyota City Nature Sanctuary (from non-museum circle) Insect specimens of Tochigi Prefectural Museum Brown algae specimens of Komatsu City Museum Vascular plant specimens of Toyama Science Museum A crowdsourcing approach to collecting photo-based insect and plant observation records Insect specimens of Komatsu City Museum FRA-PLANKTON DATASET A Specimen List of Hymenophyllaceae of Seram and Ambon collected on Indonesian-Japanese botanical expeditions 1983–1986 Insect specimens of Toyama Science Museum Fish specimens of Ryukyu University Museum (Fujukan) Specimen records of spiders (Arachnida: Araneae) by monthly census for 3 years in forest areas of Yakushima Island, Japan Aracnid Specimen Collection Deposited in Echigo-Matsunoyama Museum of Natural Science Insect specimens of Obihiro Centennial City Museum Mesozoa collection of National Museum of Nature and Science Hokkaido University Coleoptera Collection Plant distribution data with photograph Vascular plant specimens of National Museum of Nature and Science (TNS) Kyoto University Reptile Collection Insect specimens of Kashihara City Museum of Insect Plant Specimens of Kurashiki Museum of Natural History Herbarium Specimens of Tokushima Prefectural Museum, Japan Insect specimens of Omogo Mountain Museum Fish Specimens of Graduate School of Bioresources Mie University Bryophyte specimens database of Mr. Tsutomu Kodama collection Fish specimen database of Osaka Museum of Natural History Vascular plant specimens of Sugadaira Research Station, Mountain Science Center, University of Tsukuba Hymenopteran specimen database of Osaka Museum of Natural History NIAES Coleoptera Specimen Database Fish collection of National Museum of Nature and Science Fish Collection of Natural History Museum and Institute, Chiba The 2nd and 3rd National Survey on the Natural Environment: Vegetation Survey (common species) Spermatophyta specimens of Iwate Prefectural Museum Vascular Plants Collection of Sagamihara City Museum Plant specimens in the Museum of Nature and Human Activities, Hyogo Prefecture, Japan Coleoptera specimen database of Osaka Museum of Natural History The 2nd and 3rd National Survey on the Natural Environment: Vegetation Survey (rare species) Lepidoptera specimen database of Osaka Museum of Natural History Insects specimen database of Osaka Museum of Natural History Bryophyte specimens of Toyama Science Museum Arthropoda (excepting insect) collection of Osaka Museum of Natural History Occurrence data of woody plants in the Ginkakuzi-san National Forest Amphibian specimens of Toyama Science Museum Specimen-based records of geometrid, pyralid, and crambid moths (Lepidoptera) with location information from the collection of Dr. Hiroshi Inoue Invertebrate (minor phyla) collection of Osaka Museum of Natural History Molluscan collection of Osaka Museum of Natural History Plant specimens deposited in Osaka Museum of Natural History, Japan Insect collection of Itami City Museum of Insects Vascular Plant Specimens of Kochi Prefectural Makino Botanical Garden Zoological specimens of Gifu Prefectural Museum Pycnogonid collection of the National Museum of Nature and Science Plant specimens of Kiritappu Wetland Center Insecta specimens of Okutama Visitor Center, Tokyo Diversity and community structure of pelagic cnidarians in south-east Asian tropical marginal Seas Underwater video and still-image dataset of fishes and other aquatic animals in Lake Biwa, Japan, observed via carp-mounted video loggers. Gunma Museum of Natural History, Arachnid Specimens Insecta Specimens of Kawasaki Municipal Science Museum Mammal specimens of Komatsu City Museum Mammal specimens of Kawasaki Municipal Science Museum Insect specimens of Ryukyu University Museum (Fujukan) Vascular Plant Specimen database of Kanagawa Prefectural Museum of Natural History Orthoptera collection of Hiratsuka City Museum Gunma Museum of Natural History, Vascular Plant Specimen Gunma Museum of Natural History, Insect Specimen Gunma Museum of Natural History, Molluscan Specimen Gunma Museum of Natural History, Fish Specimen Gunma Museum of Natural History, Amphibia and Reptile Specimen Gunma Museum of Natural History, Mammal Specimen Insect Collection of Natural History Museum and Institute, Chiba Fungi specimen database of Kanagawa Prefectural Museum of Natural History Fungal Specimens of National Museum of Nature and Science (TNS) Vascular plants collection of Hiratsuka City Museum Insecta collection of Museum of Natural and Environmental History, Shizuoka Vascular Plant Specimens of the URO Herbarium (Faculty of Education, University of the Ryukyus) Annelida specimens of Ryukyu University Museum (Fujukan) Plant specimens of Kushiro City Museum Bird specimens of Komatsu City Museum Mammal Specimens of The Cattle Museum Crabs from the Philippines and Thailand Annual Census on Waterfowl (Anatidae) Population Coleoptera Specimens of Yamaguchi prefectural Yamaguchi Museum A dataset for vascular plant diversity monitoring for the natural World Heritage site on Amami-Oshima Island, Tokunoshima Island, and the northern Okinawa Island Survey data of tidal flats on the Monitoring sites 1000 project, BDCJ Bryophytes specimens of Mitake Visitor Center Odonata collection of National Museum of Nature and Science Pogonophoran collection of the National Museum of Nature and Science Lepidopterous specimens of Yamagata Prefectural Museum Monitoring Sites 1000 Satoyama Birds Mollusca specimens of Manazuru Shell Museum Mollusca specimens of Natural History Museum, Kishiwada City Vascular Plant Specimens of the RYU Herbarium (Faculty of Science, University of the Ryukyus) Herpetological (amphibian & reptile) specimens of Ryukyu University Museum (Fujukan) Xenacoelomorpha collection of National Museum of Nature and Science Fish Collection of Coastal Branch of Natural History Museum and Institute, Chiba Insect specimens of Tokushima Prefectural Museum Bird specimens of Toyota City Nature Sanctuary Mammal specimens of Tochigi Prefectural Museum Insect specimens of Hokkaido University Hymenoptera collection of National Museum of Nature and Science Kamptozoa collection of National Museum of Nature and Science